At its eighth meeting, the Party Executive of the German Communist Party (DKP) addressed a much-discussed issue within the communist movement: the national question. UZ publishes an abridged and lightly edited version of the report presented on this subject.
The most important point—and this must be absolutely clear before we discuss and examine the subject—is the purpose of this report: we must develop our own conception of what our country should be like and how it can become our country. Listing what is wrong is insufficient. We need positive objectives and tasks for struggle that enable people themselves to take effective action.
We are compelled to take a position for two reasons:
- This country exists in a period of decline of the capitalist system. Like its predecessors, the present government is increasingly ruining it, now at an alarming pace. Moreover, those in power are greatly increasing the danger of war.
- The AfD presents itself as the Alternative for Germany not merely through its name. It appeals to the hopes of many people that this country has a positive future. It appropriates the concepts of nation, fatherland and related notions, presenting itself as the only force capable of halting the country's decline. It plays the nationalist card in response to people's concerns about their social security.
Our objective must therefore be to offer people a different vision of this country's future. We want and need to develop our own narrative.
Nation and State
The nation is a political and social product. The concept arose from the bourgeoisie's need for a unified sphere of influence. The great nations—Great Britain, La Grande Nation—were invariably also nations of colonialism and empire. This also makes clear why we describe German imperialism as having arrived too late and received too little, and why we derive its particular aggressiveness from this circumstance. While Britain, France, Portugal, Spain and the Netherlands were already consolidated states and major colonial powers, the territory of the future German Empire remained a patchwork of a few large principalities—above all Prussia and Bavaria—and many small ones, whose unification was obstructed by divergent particular interests. Thus, following Alfred Norden, the German Empire subsequently established in 1871 was more a state of nationalities than a nation-state.
The German Empire entered the race for the colonial partition of the world only in the final quarter of the nineteenth century, acquiring widely scattered colonial possessions of limited economic value:
- In Africa, the German Empire subjugated Togo, Cameroon and German South West Africa (all in 1884), followed by German East Africa (1885).
- In the Pacific, its acquisitions were the Bismarck Archipelago and Kaiser-Wilhelmsland (both in 1884), the Marshall Islands (1885), and the Mariana and Caroline Islands, Palau and Samoa (all in 1899).
Norden describes the situation after the Franco-Prussian War of 1870–71 as follows: “Sated and strengthened by the billions flowing in from the French war indemnity, the German bourgeoisie shortly thereafter, in the early 1880s, opened a new, dark chapter in the oppression of peoples through its colonial policy.”
Nationalism played a major role for Germany—that is, in the formation of a German Empire. It provided the bond that made it possible to bring together the many small states. In this connection, it is also significant that the bourgeois revolution of 1848 failed on this question as well, and that imperial unification took place only in 1871. Norden writes: “Although the people of Berlin triumphed in the barricade fighting of 18–19 March 1848, the bourgeoisie squandered that victory: out of fear of the young working class—which had supplied the majority of the fighters and of those killed on 18 and 19 March—it voluntarily submitted once again to the feudal powers and concluded with them that fatal alliance which was to leave its imprint on Germany for the next seventy years.”
This also makes clear that the national question cannot be separated from the question of whether it arises in an oppressed or an oppressor nation. Lenin drew our attention to this. We examined the matter at length at the fourth meeting of the Party Executive and concluded that present-day Germany is an oppressor nation which, at the same time, consciously subordinates itself to US imperialism and to imperialism's common struggle against the loss of its hegemony.
A Field of Tension
On this subject, Manfred Sohn wrote in the invitation to a symposium organised by the Marx-Engels Foundation:
“The tension inherent in the national question is already identified in the Communist Manifesto: ‘The Communists are further reproached with desiring to abolish countries and nationality. The working men have no country. We cannot take from them what they have not got. Since the proletariat must first of all acquire political supremacy, must rise to be the leading class of the nation, must constitute itself the nation, it is, so far, itself national, though not at all in the bourgeois sense of the word.’
“This was written at the turn of 1847–48. It must therefore be borne in mind that the process of nation-state formation in Europe had not yet been completed: Germany was still a patchwork of principalities. Nevertheless, it is evident that there is a tension between the statement that proletarians have no fatherland and the proposition that they should constitute themselves as a nation, in terms of the practical policies to be derived from them.
“This tension continues to shape the world communist movement to this day.
“I wish to preface this introduction with a thesis: communist parties have invariably failed in the task of raising the proletariat ‘to be the leading class of the nation’—in other words, of building parties with the mass influence necessary to make victory possible—whenever they have insisted solely on the first statement. Historically, they have always been successful when they have made both sides of these passages from the Manifesto the basis of their policies, and thus have also pursued national policies in the sense of these statements.”
Sohn offers the following interim conclusions from the debate on the national question from a Marxist perspective:
- The nation is a structure of human societies that did not exist before capitalism and will no longer exist under developed communism.
- It also exists under socialism, which—as Walter Ulbricht rightly formulated it—is a relatively independent stage in the epochal transition from capitalism to communism, and thus from the epoch of class societies to classless society.
- In this respect, the nation serves as a bridge between the final phase of class society—that is, capitalism—and the first stage of communism—that is, socialism.
- The historical dissolution of class society thus begins within the nation. It is possible, however, only in the form of a socialist nation.
- With regard to the German nation, the GDR is the leaven in this process, which historically still has to be fought through. That is why it remains so difficult for German capital to digest.
- This fermentation will become all the more intense as the decline of the German nation unfolds in the course of decolonisation, which is reaching its historical completion before our eyes: the liberation of the world from five hundred years of oppression by Western Europe and its US offshoot.
- This decline, manifest in deindustrialisation, declining prosperity, social cutbacks, militarisation, a growing lack of prospects—especially for young people—and other symptoms, reopens, unless it ends in catastrophe, Ulbricht's prospect of a socialist German nation.
The AfD and the Antideutsche
Lenin calls upon us to examine carefully the specific characteristics of each country. Let us first consider two manifestations with which we are confronted in Germany.
Number 1: the AfD. Its name alone appropriates two important concepts in the political and, above all, ideological struggle. “Alternative” appeals to the discontent of sections of the population, especially within the working class, with the policies of successive governments over recent years and decades. “For Germany” serves as a weapon directed against migrants, “parasites” and women—who are said to bear too few children—and fuels a reactionary nationalism that frequently assumes chauvinist features and, by excluding the class question, conveys elements of the notion of a Volksgemeinschaft, a supposedly unified national community.
Number 2: the Antideutsche, or “anti-Germans”. Gerhard Hanloser discussed them in junge Welt on 11 April 2024: “The Antideutsche may have disappeared as ‘Antideutsche’. Yet even when they constituted a recognisable milieu, they were ‘the mainstream in sectarian garb’. Some of their positions have now become part of Germany's ‘reason of state’. They are not a forgotten marginal phenomenon, but rather a contemporary expression of the ‘misery of German conditions’, characterised by militarist thinking, pro-Western conformism and contempt for the left's history of internationalism and anti-imperialism. For a variety of reasons, they serve the official German ‘reason of state’ of unconditional support for Israel. Nothing critical remains in this position; an anti-German stance in the emphatically positive sense of refusal to accommodate, nonconformism and opposition to the state has long ceased to be discernible in it.”
Hanloser continues: “When the GDR collapsed in 1989–90, the left in the Federal Republic lost its bearings. Germany, suddenly enlarged under the leadership of Federal Chancellor Helmut Kohl, constituted a threat—not only to other countries, not only to everything that could be regarded as ‘un-German’, but also to the left itself. Not least for this reason, a mood and stance defining themselves as ‘anti-German’ were widespread within the radical left in the early 1990s. The initial slogan ‘Never again Germany!’ seemed more than justified in the face of an explosion of everyday racism that followed immediately upon German reunification. The pogroms in Rostock and Hoyerswerda, the sharp increase in antisemitic cemetery desecrations and the awakening of new great-power ambitions demonstrated that the alarmed criticism of Germany at the time of reunification, voiced abroad and shared by significant sections of the left, had been prophetic.”
National Nihilism
Far more dangerous than the activities of the Antideutsche, largely confined to the left's own milieu, is the fact that most groups identifying with the left pay little or no attention to the question of the nation. The Party Executive was right to place it on the agenda, and the Marx-Engels Foundation contributed to this work through a symposium.
In 1935, at the Seventh World Congress of the Communist International, Georgi Dimitrov observed: “For a long time, our comrades in Germany failed to take sufficient account of the wounded national feelings of the masses and their indignation against the Treaty of Versailles. They treated the vacillations of the peasantry and the petty bourgeoisie with disdain; they were late in putting forward the programme of social and national liberation; and when they did formulate it, they did not know how to apply it in accordance with the concrete needs and level of the masses. They did not even know how to popularise it widely among the masses.”
A significant element in this underestimation—as in the underestimation of fascism—was the assumption of the Communist International and the KPD that socialism was the immediate objective of struggle. Reorienting towards a policy of defending capitalist states was a difficult and painful process.
The factors at work today are different. The counter-revolution and the loss of the Soviet Union, together with “reunification”, play a major role. Both greatly intensified anti-communism and deprived us of the GDR, a country that we could sincerely have embraced as our fatherland. We rightly describe Germany's resurgence, with the imperialist plans it aggressively pursues abroad and increasingly repressive measures at home, as a reactionary and militarist restructuring of the state. Continuity is evident in German capital's strategy for Europe. All these factors have deepened unease about this Germany across the left, to the point of national nihilism.
In an article in junge Welt of 8 April 2015, Andreas Wehr directs our attention to the ideological background of this nihilism, which appears in the guise of “Hurrah for Europe”, and reaches the following conclusion: “The ‘nation-state’ is abandoned as a field of struggle, without an adequate new one being identified. The exploited and socially disadvantaged are left to their own devices, since their traditional organisations—trade unions and left-wing parties—no longer offer them any prospect. In the most literal sense, they are offered stones instead of bread.”
Germany
The difficulties that many of us have with “Germany” have, first of all, historical causes: its birth through war. Making common cause with the “hereditary enemy” to crush the Paris Commune. Aggressive imperialism. Colonialism and the “Hun speech”. Nazi dictatorship, with “Do you want total war?”, concentration camps and genocide. No liberation in 1945 arising from the people themselves. The resurgence of the old forces after 1945. “Reunification” and a renewed bid for world-power status, dramatically announced in 1999 by the war against Yugoslavia. Hatred of Russians and support for Ukrainian fascists. Arms deliveries to Israel and denial of the genocide against the Palestinian people. Abject servility towards the United States and its war against Iran. Resurgent militarism. Racism and xenophobia. Historical revisionism. Bullying those below while bowing to those above. After 1945, most Germans acknowledged no guilt, seeing themselves rather as victims. Added to this is a social democracy that not only produced a bloodhound but also regards itself as a pillar of the state.
German literature contains hundreds of examples showing that revolutionary minds have always struggled with this fatherland.
Bertolt Brecht:
“O Germany, pale mother!
How sullied you sit
Among the peoples.
Among the stained
You stand out.
O Germany, pale mother!
How your sons have
Maltreated you,
So that you sit among the peoples
An object of mockery or of fear!”
Or Erich Kästner:
“Do you know the land
Where cannons bloom?
You do not know it?
You will come to know it!
There the company executives stand
Proud and bold
In offices as though they were barracks.
There freedom does not ripen.
There it remains green.
Whatever is built—
It always turns into barracks.
Do you know the land
Where cannons bloom?
You do not know it?
You will come to know it!”
Many were driven out of the country. For those who remained, often only their thoughts were free.
And are we supposed to love this country? This people of poets and thinkers that became a “people of judges and executioners”?
In January 1969, Gustav Heinemann (SPD), Federal President from 1969 to 1974, was asked in an interview with Der Spiegel whether he did not love this state. He replied somewhat curtly: “Nonsense, I do not love states; I love my wife, and that is that!” This was a time when efforts to bring the crimes of the Nazi era back into public consciousness had only just begun, and love of the fatherland still meant treating Hitler as an unfortunate aberration.
After the historical and political dimension, this is the second element that makes life with this Germany difficult for us: the heavy ideological baggage of a nationalism bound up with the decline of capitalism, serving only the aggressive glorification of one's own state. Behind the “we”, at worst, lurks the ugly face of the Volksgemeinschaft, the master-race mentality, chauvinism and jingoism; at the very least, it is a sentimental invocation that obscures contradictions and questions of class.
Our Nation
We must and can free ourselves ideologically from these burdens. We understand the nation as the Marxist classics taught us to understand it: as a field of class struggle. We approach our own history as Brecht tells us in his poem: “Let others speak of their shame; I speak of mine.” Viewed in this way, we are indeed patriots. With its “Appeal of the Central Committee of the Communist Party for the Building of an Anti-Fascist, Democratic Germany” of June 1945, the KPD presented a clear, analytical and forward-looking document that assesses history and outlines political tasks without nationalist bombast. The second document that can serve as a guide for us today is Ulbricht's speech of 21 April 1966, “The Road to the Future Fatherland of the Germans”. (See UZ of 31 July)
We must not, however, make the mistake of scorning an emotional attachment to the piece of earth on which one lives. Heinrich Heine offers us an approach to this in his poem “Night Thoughts”:
“Germany will endure for ever,
It is a country sound at heart.
With its oaks and its lime trees
I shall always find it again.I would not long for Germany
So deeply,Were my mother not there;
The fatherland will never perish,
But the old woman may die.”
It is our family, our friends and our comrades who sustain our lives. This is what we can say to every ranting nationalist. Our love is for people.
To make this distinction clear in conceptual terms as well, we distinguish between national consciousness, which reflects the “conditions of existence, historical development, current situation and the essential tasks of the nation arising from them, from the standpoint of a particular class”, and nationalism, which emerged as the bourgeoisie developed into a reactionary class and is itself reactionary and divisive.
The nation is our field of struggle, without our catering to nationalism. Everything concerning the nation and our attitude towards it is always a minefield, because the subject is emotionally charged. Love of the fatherland, patriotism, nationalism—these are the words with which we must contend, and the difficulty lies in addressing the question “What do we want for this country?” without falling into an emotional trap. The nation is the working class's field of struggle—no more, but also no less. We cannot pretend to be indifferent to what becomes of this country. And we must provide answers now, rather than asking people to wait for socialism, which will supposedly resolve everything.
Connections
We can often imagine socialism as the only remaining way out of Germany's predicament. Ultimately, that is indeed correct—but we live here and now. And here and now, people are subjected to political, social, legal and ideological oppression; they are deprived of their capacity to act independently, persecuted and harmed. Like most others on the left, we are occupied with indicting this state.
This became particularly evident with the proposed slogan “For a Government of Peace”. Irrespective of whether one endorses this precise formulation, it expresses the task we have to resolve and indicates the direction in which our policy must develop. The Marx-Engels Foundation's invitation to its symposium on the national question put it as follows: “The national question—that is, the interests of the working class, other working people and the younger generation—arises not only for peoples oppressed by imperialism. It also arises for the peoples of the developed capitalist states. If communist parties in these countries wish to become mass parties again, they will have to answer the question posed by their peoples: ‘If what you say is right, what does that mean for my life here in this country?’ It cannot be sufficient to tell them that they live in an imperialist country which has plundered other countries for centuries and that the interests of other peoples must now simply take precedence.”
Nevertheless, these positions are necessary—particularly when we seek to answer a question repeatedly used by reactionaries to divide the working class. We state unequivocally: our class brothers and sisters are all members of the working class who live here, regardless of their origins. We must oppose every nationalist attempt at division. The national question cannot be separated from the class question.
In the struggles against the all-out assault on our social rights, we shall develop a mass line. This means presenting a conception of what a genuine alternative for Germany would have to look like: proud and independent, peaceful, democratic and socially just, humanist, committed to people and nature, protecting the weak and imposing obligations upon property ownership. We shall develop our own narrative, rather than serve that of our adversary.
We shall formulate central demands, orient our propaganda and, above all, our agitation towards them, and develop a corresponding policy of alliances. We shall develop viable demands that people can take up. First and foremost, this means investigating their actual circumstances, needs and views, taking them seriously and responding to them through agitation. In dialectical terms, we shall begin with the internal contradictions. We shall move beyond an accusatory stance and formulate the task as follows: what should the Germany in which we can and wish to live be like?
Brecht's “Children's Hymn” sums up this direction aptly, correctly and beautifully:
“Spare neither grace nor effort,
Neither passion nor understanding,
That a good Germany may flourish
Like any other good country.That the peoples may not turn pale
As before a plunderer,
But extend their hands to us
As to other peoples.Neither above nor below
Other peoples do we wish to stand,
From the sea to the Alps,
From the Oder to the Rhine.And because we improve this country,
We love and protect it;
And may it seem the dearest to us,
As theirs does to other peoples.”
Definitions
The Dictionary of History states the following concerning the nation:
“A historical structural and developmental form of human society, arising in accordance with historical laws alongside the emergence of the capitalist socioeconomic formation, and undergoing a fundamental social transformation in the transition from capitalism to socialism. The nation provides a necessary framework within which productive forces, social and political structures, culture, ideology, science and ways of life can develop in accordance with the conditions of the respective social order. In a long-term historical process, the determining socioeconomic and class foundations of the nation combine with existing ethnic components—including language, customs, practices, traditions, habits of life and social-psychological characteristics—to form a distinctive unity in each case. Nations generally organise themselves politically as nation-states. Through the state, the ruling class of the time realises its claim to national leadership and decisively shapes the development of the content and forms of national coexistence, as well as relations with other nations.”
In his work Marxism and the National Question, Stalin writes:
“A nation is a historically constituted, stable community of people, formed on the basis of a common language, territory, economic life and psychological make-up manifested in a common culture. It is thus clear that, in reality, there is no single distinguishing characteristic of a nation. There is only a combination of characteristics, of which, when nations are compared, sometimes one—national character—sometimes another—language—and sometimes a third—territory or economic conditions—stands out more clearly. A nation is the combination of all these characteristics taken together.”