The authors of the chapter “Invoking the Image of the Enemy” (“Feindbildansprache”) in the army field manual “Command in Combat” (“Führung im Gefecht”) would be delighted with EU Council President Ursula von der Leyen (CDU). In her latest State of the European Union address, von der Leyen spoke of “Russian interference or disinformation. The labels may differ, but their objective is the same. They despise our values and want to shatter our European unity”. Unfortunately for her, it was none other than Germany's Federal Court of Justice that has now put a small obstacle in her way. On 21 October, it examined a matter that, in a state governed by the rule of law, should never have required clarification by the highest judicial instance.
The Russian-Uzbek businessman Alisher Usmanov was placed under European Union sanctions in 2022. The reasons given included assertions that he was “a close confidant of Vladimir Putin” and acted as “an economic front man for the Russian president”. Usmanov considered this a violation of his personality rights and filed a lawsuit against the EU in Hamburg Regional Court in December 2023. As usual, the judge responsible in the Hamburg civil division ordered the claim to be served on the defendant in Brussels. But a step normally completed within two weeks did not take place. The claim remained unserved.
The president of Hamburg Regional Court himself had prevented compliance with the judicial order for service. It has since emerged that the Federal Office of Justice, in collusion with the Federal Foreign Office, had internally instructed the Hamburg court president to put the statement of claim on hold. The instruction of 3 November 2023 read: “We do not want this; or rather, it would be incompatible with the supranational character of these measures for them to be influenced or even reviewed by national courts of the member states.” This glimpse, disclosed by chance, lays bare the true nature of all the empty talk about the “community of values of the free West”. The principles of judicial independence, guaranteed access to the courts and the separation of powers enshrined in the Basic Law become mere decoration when the obsessively propagated myth of “internal and external threats” is at stake.
Three years after the lawsuit was filed, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has now restored something that should be self-evident. Until the next time: apart from allowing the claim to be sent to Brussels, the BGH says nothing about this scandal. Foreign-policy “considerations” are not a procedural prerequisite — many thanks; we have learned a great deal.
It now becomes clear why the challenges to measures in the EU's 17th sanctions package have also been left pending for an unusually long time. The package imposed sanctions on individuals and media outlets for “destabilising activities”. It initiated a witch-hunt against German citizens and people living in Germany. To this day, the measures include asset freezes, entry bans and a prohibition on making funds or economic resources available to those affected. At issue, in particular, are the actions for annulment brought by four applicants before the General Court of the European Union (EuG) in Luxembourg.
The journalist Hüseyin Doğru was placed on the sanctions list on the grounds that he allegedly had “close financial and organisational links to organisations and actors involved in state propaganda in Russia” and systematically supplied “false information on politically controversial issues”. Thomas Röper, who lives in Russia and has also been under sanctions since 20 May 2025, was accused of having used “his network (…) systematically to spread misinformation about Russia's war of aggression”. He allegedly “denies the legitimacy of the Ukrainian government”, culminating in the direct “manipulation of public opinion in Germany”. Similar allegations were made against the blogger Alina Lipp: she allegedly delegitimises the Ukrainian government and seeks to influence public opinion in Russia's favour. In December last year, the former Swiss General Staff colonel and intelligence officer Jacques Baud was targeted, sanctioned for assisting “Russia's destabilising activities”. The principal accusation: regular appearances in “pro-Russian” media. His sanctions were recently extended until October 2027 despite the ongoing proceedings.
The 17th sanctions package reminds not only legal historians of a “modern” version of medieval law. At the time, it was called the imperial ban, outlawry and banishment. Those declared outlaws stood “outside the peace”, lost all their possessions and were excluded from the community. The practice reached its heyday shortly before the collapse of the Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation. It was “ultima ratio regum” — the last resort of kings — and ultimately remained merely a sign of their weakness.