Scotland News
By our Scottish political affairs correspondent
Once again, we are forced to turn our attention to the ferry question. It has been announced that the Glen Rosa, the second of the famous much delayed and over budget ferries being built (and rebuilt) at the Ferguson Marine shipyard at Port Glasgow is to be delayed yet again.
It was supposed to be delivered before Christmas, but at best it will be a Valentine’s Day surprise. Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn said the handover date will be in February so that the new ship can get a new propeller before a single paying passenger boards the ship. For the technically minded “this enables new propellers to be fitted and the ship’s liquefied natural gas (LNG) fuel systems to be filled and commissioned only once. Doing this work now avoids the need to recall the vessel later”.
Another delay is the last thing West Coast islanders need. The rest of the Caledonian MacBrayne fleet is well past its best, with 15 of 33 vessels now at least aged 30 or over.
CalMac say its ships should be replaced after 25 years’ service. However, in 2012 the SNP extended the working life to 30 years. Today 15 ships are over that. The oldest is the Isle of Cumbrae, which entered service in 1977 and was scheduled to be replaced in 2016, but still works as a backup despite constantly breaking down.
At that time the Transport Secretary declared that “our Ferries Plan will enable our rural and remote communities to thrive and continue to make a significant contribution to Scotland’s economy.” Unfortunately, the only “significant contribution” is a negative one.
The reality is that aged ships keep breaking down. In some cases the slightly younger ships sent to replace them follow suit. These breakdowns mean that the islands, heavily dependent on tourism lose out as many potential visitors are unwilling to take the risk of spending their holiday sitting in a mainland harbour queue. Islanders still vote SNP regardless.
At the parish pump
Local government councillors are at war with the Standards Commission for Scotland (SCS) – an august body which boasts of being “responsible for encouraging high standards of behaviour by councillors and those appointed to boards of devolved public bodies...including the promotion and enforcement of the Codes of Conduct and to issue guidance to councils and devolved public bodies”. The SCS can adjudicate on alleged breaches of the Codes of Conduct, and where a breach is found, to apply a sanction.
But this often sparks off even more argument. Many councillors are up in arms at the rulings of the Standards Commission, sometimes with good reason. Many recent cases seem to be about councillors coming under scrutiny for the grave crime of querying the actions of senior council officials, and even worse, telling them to do some work.
One case is that of Independent Aberdeen city councillor, Jennifer Stewart, who was hauled before the Commission and suspended because she objected to the SNP Lord Provost complaining about her speaking too long during a council chamber debate.
She claims that at her hearing she was interrupted at least 14 times and accused the panel of refusing to hear evidence and witnesses which would have cleared her. She was suspended from all council work in August last year for four months for “disrespectful conduct and harassment” against His Lordship.
Aberdeen was famous for its legendary fishwives who were no shrinking violets, but the Commission seems to be anxious to snuff them out. Mrs Stewart told The Herald that the disciplinary proceedings were politically motivated, claiming the SNP had “always had it in for me”, describing the case as “payback time”.
Certainly, the Commission has become more energetic. In 2024/25 there were 244 cases involving councillors, compared to 111 in 2014/15. In response to this both Dumfries & Galloway and East Renfrewshire council have called for an independent review and Edinburgh councillors have voted to express no confidence in the SCS.
In SNP/Green run Glasgow Labour Councillor Fiona Higgins has been in the front line.
She was hauled before the SCS when she accused an ex-finance director of misusing his influence to “wilfully and cynically mislead councillors and the public” about planned cuts to teacher jobs.
In this earlier case the Commission was accused of preventing Councillor Higgins from presenting important evidence, something the Scottish Law Commission agreed with. Its Chair said the SCS had “shut its ears” to submissions from the councillor “and in so doing acted unlawfully”. The SCS has not taken this well, and is appealing to the Court of Session.
Little wonder that East Renfrewshire Labour Councillor Katie Pragnell Lees said “many of us will have followed Fiona’s case when the SCS was questioned, and it still feels very defensive. There seems to be no rhyme or reason to when councillors do get censored”.
In addition to demands for the local government minister Jenny Gilruth to launch an independent review of the SCS, eyebrows have been raised about the SCS’s habit of destroying records of very recent cases, which makes it impossible to query them.